Loading...
Answers
MenuHow should one go about pricing and creating a subscription model for a business?
I have built a startup and am looking to offer it's services through a subscription model, but have no experience pricing something like this up.
What are some of the key tips, things to think about and must do's when trying to create a subscription model?
Answers


You have two questions. One is how to actually establish a price or pricing plans, the other are tactics most useful after pricing has been established.
I think Laura provides some great tactics around pricing but as I read her answer, I think it addresses the tactics part less than the pricing part so I'll focus exclusively on how to find the right price.
First, I'd suggest you go to http://www.harrisonmetal.com/ and scroll down the page to find their workshops on pricing. I've attended their class on the subject in-person and they have published the course materials on their site.
Pricing is part art, part science. It comes from understanding what other offerings exist in the marketplace and how your offering differentiates. So for example, customer development that focuses on understanding how your customers perceive your offering against competitive offerings would provide clues and insights into whether it might make sense to price your offering higher or lower to your competitors. Pricing is also entirely dependent on it's related messaging. Decisions are made and confirmed by two entirely different parts of our brain, and so appealing to intuition or emotion without providing context for the logic/rational part of the decision will often fail to complete the sale.
Happy to talk to you about any of this in a call with you, if you'd like.


Pricing a subscription model can be a bit complicated depending on the product you are offering. These are some of the factors that came in to play with one of my SaaS software clients.
First, determine your fixed cost per customer. Most entrepreneurs in the SaaS (Software as a Service) subscription space do not realize there is a very real cost per user.
Look at all your infrastructure costs. How many concurrent users can your infrastructure handle before you have to scale? What are the variable costs based on usage such as per-user storage space requirements? Number of emails allowed (if that is part of the offer)? Bandwidth?
Overselling the infrastructure is an acceptable practice. Meaning, if you use a 20-1 ratio, you are saying for every one real user accessing the system at any given moment, you can have 20 subscribers paying for the service. The assumption is that all 20 will not generally access the system concurrently.
What will be your expected user support load? Depending on the simplicity or complexity of your offering, your users may or may not need to contact support. The simpler the program to use, the higher the customer to support ratio can be. For instance, if you remember Countrywide Financial, they staffed approximately one customer service rep for every 684 loans they serviced. A 684-1 ratio. Your ratio will probably not be that high with software.
Look at your competitors. What do they charge for similar services? Decide if you are competing on price or quality. I generally prefer to not compete on price. But, that is a situational decision.
Keep your pricing model simple. The more options you add, whether the number of plans or the add-ons, the higher the shopping cart abandonment will be.
I've been involved in subscription models since 1997 when I first created an online real estate agent portal and sold subscriptions to agents in the US and Canada. Give me a call if you have any further questions. I'm certain I can save you time, money and a lot of grieve.
All the best!
Kevin McCarthy
Related Questions
-
I'm running a two sided marketplace. Should I charge a subscription fee on the supply side or take a commission off each transaction?
I have participated in marketplaces that charge for access (subscription fee) and ones that do per transaction charges. I have found that I prefer the per transaction charges as I am essentially paying a commission for the lead / opportunity, which is much more palatable. I have worked with platforms that charge a fee for leads, which is more akin to a subscription fee. The problem is that you are asking providers to pay for the hope of making money where as on the per transaction you are asking providers to pay for actual revenue. Elance and Upwork have a hybrid model that also seems to work well. You can bid on so many jobs for free and pay a percentage of revenue. They have higher levels where you buy more credits to bid. On Elance I started on the free level and had success so now I subscribe. This is an interesting form of the freemium model. Hope this gives you some insight. Let me know if I can be of further help.
-
What is the right business/revenue model for a personalized online learning platform for business professionals?
There are merits to both options, but unless your economics dictate one over the other, the choice should be made by your consumers. I would suggest that you use landing pages to test both pricing models and let the relative click-through-rates tell you which is the right way to go. Validate the consumer preferred model before you commit to it. You may discover one as a clear winner overall, or that one wins out in a key market segment. You may also find that the distribution is fairly even. Keep in mind that it is possible to utilize both - think Amazon selling audio books, but also offering Audible Subscriptions. Ultimately, you'll want to make sure that the economics work for you - and focus on maximizing customer LTV (life time value - ie the total you'll earn per customer over the lifetime of that customer). I'm happy to explain the process of testing these (even before the product exists) in detail. Just shoot me a message.
-
What is the best pricing (business model) to apply to a marketplace?
I like to separate your question into 2 sub-questions: #1 How do we determine which side to charge? #2 How much is the right amount to charge? On #1, my answer is that you can charge the side(s) for whom you add the most value. In your examples, Uber really solves a big problem for drivers, it's that they sit idle for a good part of the day, so are willing to pay a lot for new leads. (their alternative is no work) Consumers are charged more for the convenience of a private car but they are probably not so much willing to pay more for a taxi, even if they can hail one from their phones. For AirBnB, it's a mix, it's a way for landlords to monetize idle capacity which they are willing to pay for, but it's also a way for a renter to pay less than they would normally pay for a hotel. On #2 (how much), I like to triangulate a number of factors: - What's the maximum amount I can charge one side, while still being a good deal for them. - How much do I need to charge so that I can become profitable? (the economics are quite different if you charge 3% vs. 12%) - What are comparable services charging for substitutes/competitive offerings? I will just add that there is no formulaic way to determine pricing strategies (curated vs. open), and it's a lot more about what's the comparable and what the value delivered is. That's how I approached the question while deciding the business model at ProBueno.com (my startup)
-
Freemium v.s. free trial for a marketplace?
It depends on a number of factors but I'd boil it down to two key things to start: 1) What is your real cost to provide a free plan or trial? 2) Who exactly is your customer and what are they used to paying and who and how do they pay today? When you say "online workforce marketplace" it sounds as though you're placing virtual workers. If that's the case, or if you're paying for the supply side of the marketplace, the question is how much can you subsidize demand? Depending on where you're at in the process, I'd also question how much you can learn about the viability of your marketplace by offering a free version, assuming again, that free is actually a real cost to you. I was part of a SaaS project that started charging people for early access based mostly on just a good landing page (we clearly stated they were pre-paying) and were amazed at the response. I've also run a SaaS product that offered free trials and realized that the support costs and hand-holding and selling required to convert from free trial to paid wasn't worth it, this despite the product's significant average ARR. You might be better off providing a "more information" sign-up form (to capture more leads) and let them ask for a free trial while only showing your paid options. I've been amazed at the lead capture potential from a simple "have questions? Click here and we'll contact you" This is all the generalized advice I can offer based on the limited information I have, but happy to dive-in further if you'd like on a call.
-
How do you get traction for a B2C app? More importantly, how does a Free B2C app make any money?
B2C apps typically use a freemium model to make money off of in-app purchases and ad revenue. You could also make a paid monthly subscription model work in several categories, such as Newsstand. The challenge is finding the balance between giving enough functionality away for free so that your app can attract and retain users. Only if user retention is high does your app stand to monetize well over time. A word of caution though related to free-to-play apps: http://m.ign.com/articles/2014/04/10/two-thirds-of-mobile-free-to-play-gamers-quit-after-24-hours. Basically, the only safe bet in mobile development in particular (and business in general) is to create something beautiful, unique, and entertaining (or helpful), and then to market, market, market it and build a tribe of fans. Hope this helps, Austin