Loading...
Answers
MenuIs it better to have focus on one service offering or have many service offerings to gain more market share, faster?
Homejoy and Exec are the perfect examples of companies that have gone very deep into their one offering, house cleaning. While other companies like Thumbtack and MyTime have gone very wide to gain more marketshare, faster. MyTime and Thumbtack offer every service under the sun. They are creating demand and then finding supply as they go. I am not sure if one strategy is better than the other when it comes to creating a marketplace for services website.
Answers
I think there are great lessons to be learned from Exec. They started out wide, but have gone very deep on cleaning.
It depends on the core thesis of your vision. Do you have a different product experience that could be competitive to existing marketplaces? Or are you just going for land-grab?
The most important thing to understand about the services marketplace business is that it's a very localized business operation.
I believe that if you're just looking to make money, the best way to do this is to go to "secondary markets" and build up marketplaces with a plan to sell to someone who has already raised great VC and has a presence in the major markets.
If you are looking to compete in major market cities, then the safer bet is to find the very deep opportunity unless you really believe your customer experience can beat the established players.
Happy to talk this through with you in more detail.
Thinking of a new venture (either startup or a new initiative within a larger company), I would always suggest being focused on a single offering first, but with the following caveats:
1. In my view, the purpose of the first offering is to test the business hypothesis, this means not only offering but: target audience, need, specifics of the offering as the solution, and its differentiation. Really be laser-focused on all of these.
2. The only way to test that complete hypothesis is to develop, in full, an offering for a well-defined target audience, etc.
3. Once it is out and you measure adoption and success, it's critical to assess which of the assumptions are proven to be valid - could be that the need is not strong for this audience, or that there's not enough differentiation - the offering is only a part of it. You can only test this well if you developed a good offering to a well-defined audience solving a well-defined problem.
4. Then - iterate. You may need to change your offering, but you may also discover that your audience has a stronger need (they all email you and ask for it). The key here is "drop" everything and be flexible - now it is time to lose the former focus - you may need to make dramatic changes.
In my experience, companies that went through this cycle (of building a deep offering and then iterating based on the data it provides) have been the most successful.
Depends on your business model.
If you search you'll find examples of businesses that have had success with both of those models (and if you are starting with a "preference" for one or the other - beware of confirmation bias).
Your question also states that you are after "more market share, faster." Another caution is to beware of vanity numbers and lack of specificity.
If you've mapped out a good business model you'll know your numbers (projected margins, cost of acquisition, break-even points) - and instead of using vague qualitative words like "more" and "faster" you will have targets that you can track and key metrics to measure.
If you are interested in how to quickly map out a business model perhaps we should talk. In any case - Best of Luck!
Related Questions
-
I just opened a small, upscale, boutique style hair salon. Any ideas on how to market?
I have no experience with salons, but marketing is my thing. So I'll give you some suggestions of what to think about, followed by what to do. Do you have clients already (let's say from your working days at another salon)? If so, you can start profiling them. You can ask them to fill out a form in exchange for a free gift (maybe one of those creams you use in the salon), or an entry to a raffle (where the prize is valuable). In the profiling, you want to look out for which neighborhoods they live in, what kinds of activities they like to do, what kinds of social events they love to do, and their occupations. Then, using each of those profile data, you can market to more prospects who share the same characteristics. For example, - You can set aside a budget to send flyers to specific neighborhoods. In order to get people into the door, maybe you can offer a certain procedure for free in exchange for opportunities to win new regular customers. (You could theoretically do this with Groupon too, but you have less control of who comes into your door) - You could set up joint venture relationships with organizations like ball room dancing schools, professional associations, etc. You could offer an exclusive discount with those groups to entice potential customers to try out your service. More opportunities for you to win regular customers. - With certain demographic data, you can probably make the same offer by advertising on Facebook. If you target specific enough, you can get the price of acquiring the lead to be pretty cheap. You would have to figure out your typical lifetime value of your customers before deciding whether advertising on Facebook would be worthwhile. One last thing, you can offer gifts for your existing customers if they refer you people. If you have any more questions, I'm happy to chat with you. Hit me up on this platform.SL
-
What is the most creative way to introduce myself (and therefore my service) to 100 key decision-makers without selling or pitching anything?
You've answered your own question. Reach out to your prospects with the question, such as "How would you...". Ask what people want then give it to them if you can with integrity and thoughtfulness.DI
-
What are average profit margins in Ice Cream store business?
Hi! I am owner of an ice crean chain with 45 stores in Chile. We have stores in shopping centers, streets and also karts that you can put in events and parks. The average cost margin of ice cream (depends on the amount of materials you use in producing the ice cream) is around 40%. This is italian gelatto where you serve the ice cream without a specific measurement so your costs can vary due to the size of each portion you serve. About the brand you should focus on your unique value proposition and what kind of ice cream you are selling. We import the pastry from Italy and the fruits and milk from our country. Your ROI depends on your sales price and costs. If you focus on high market ice cream you can charge high and keep costs down.MF
-
How does my startup hire an affordable marketing expert?
I don't even know how to answer this. Do you know what the difference between McDonalds and the local burger joint that is filing for bankruptcy is? It's marketing. McDonalds is worth billions of dollars not because of the quality of their food, but because of their marketing. Marketing is not an expense. A janitor is an expense. Your computer is an expense. Marketing is an INVESTMENT. Would you shop around for the cheapest heart surgeon? Of course not. Because you would likely end up dead. Why, then, do you shop around for a marketing expert? Are you ok with your company going bankrupt? Is that worth the small savings to you? No. Of course not. Hire someone who is good at marketing. Hire someone who knows what they are doing. Buy yourself a Lamborghini with your profit the first quarter. Get a beach house in hawaii. Grab a yacht. Or, try to find your business the cheapest heart surgeon you can and then spend the next five years wondering why such a solid business idea failed in the first 6 months. I'm passionate about this exact topic because all those statistics you read about "70% of businesses failing in two years" are solely because of horrible marketing.AM
-
How can I go about finding a business partner for my startup?
Hello! Aside from the typical website platforms, I would recommend using Twitter's hashtags and user handles. Try following and using the ones that your potential prospect or otherwise ideal partners would be following and start sharing about your work, your progress, and outreach for a potential partner. If possible try to be local when doing so. But obviously, some to use include Startups.co, Basecamp, Inc 500, yesPHX, BetaBulls, MPV, Lean Startup, Lean Methodologies, TechCrunch, etc.HV
the startups.com platform
Copyright © 2025 Startups.com. All rights reserved.