Loading...
Answers
MenuI'm a Canadian selling ecommerce products on Amazon (US only). Need info on cross border tax clarification & if it's time to incorporate (in US or CA)
I'm Canadian selling physical products on Amazon.com (US) I'm not sure about US taxes. I've heard that I just pay tax in Canada on the income/expenses earned in the US. Income approximately $40K CAD, expenses $70k CAD. Also would now be the time to incorporate or wait till a specific dollar differential? And incorporate in Canada or the US?
Answers
Regarding US taxation of internet sales.
Since you are a foreign entity or person (in regard to the US), and there is an income tax treaty between Canada and the US, you will not be liable for US federal income tax on internet sales unless you have a “permanent establishment” in the US with which the internet sales income is effectively connected. So as long as you do not have a warehouse, physical store, sales office, etc... in the US you don't have to file US returns or remit tax to the US. Amazon should be charging to the customer and withholding any sales tax due to a state in which your products are sold. If you sell through other merchants or directly you may have to deal with this yourself.
Regarding incorporation
Incorporation is almost always a good idea from a liability standpoint as it prevents a judgement for damages from taking all your property and limits the collection to what is owned by the business, With the facts you have given I would suggest incorporating in Canada unless you have a business reason to establish a physical presence in the US. This will eliminate US taxes and related compliance costs. Once you establish a US presence you will need to begin filing returns in the US even if you are running a net operating loss. If there is no benefit to having a physical presence in the US then the related compliance costs and tax would be an unnecessary expense.
Feel free to setup a phone call if you would like to chat for a bit regarding the matter.
Thanks
What you've heard is correct not only don't you need to pay US taxes forming a US entity would actually increase your overall tax rate as you'd need to pay taxes at the higher US tax rate and then in Canada personally.
You'll almost certainly want to incorporate in your local province in Canada but probably not earn profits there initially though this depends on your tax bracket as you can end up with double taxation. At some stage you'll be better off keeping the profits in the company at the low small business tax rate and reinvesting it from there so it can compound at a preferred rate rather than taking it personally and having less to invest.
As you grow you may reach a point where it makes sense to move part or all of the company international and gain cost advantages that way.
Feel free to contact me if you'd like to discuss further.
Related Questions
-
If I get a virtual address for my company and I work from home; will I still be eligible for tax credit on my home office?
yes. As long as your main place of work is your home/office.JF
-
Do I have to file form 5472 for "additional paid-in capital"?
Yes you should be reporting the capital contributions. Under the old Form 5472 rules, it's true that only items that impacted taxable income would be reportable transactions. So, a capital contribution by you to the corporation would not be reportable, unless the equity contribution was somehow below or above a fair value contribution in exchange for services that you might provide for the corporation - essentially an imputed reportable transactions. When the IRS changed the Form 5472 rules to require non-U.S. owned single member LLC's, they expanded the reportable transaction definition to include virtually everything. The term “transaction” is defined in Treas. Regs. Section 1.482-1(i)(7) to include any sale, assignment, lease, license, loan, advance, contribution or other transfer of any interest in or a right to use any property or money, as well as the performance of any services for the benefit of, or on behalf of, another taxpayer. So, for example, contributions and distributions would be considered reportable transactions with respect to such entities. These amounts can be reported on Lines 12 and 25 with an explanatory footnote that clarities the amounts are capital contributions and not amounts that impact taxable income.JK
-
What are the tax consequences for founders if the seed round investors take common stock instead of preferred?
There shouldn't be any tax consequences for the founders if you've made 83b elections--the election meant you paid tax already on the full value of the stock at the time of the election (presumably zero) even though it was subject to future forfeiture. If you sell newly-issued stock there should be no tax impact. If you sell your own common stock, you'd pay tax on the gain, but I doubt that is what you mean here. Of course, you should not take the free advice dispensed on Clarity and consult your own tax preparer--this is not tax advice.BS
-
My startup is a NY LLC and we're hiring an employee in Bangalore, India as a developer. Am I required to pay or withhold taxes in the U.S. for him?
I have established off-shore development relationships with individuals and firms in India, Ukraine, Belarus, Russia and Korea going back to 1996. You might find it a lot smoother to have them work through an established firm in India that is already set up with all appropriate licenses, tax-reporting, payment systems, and so on. It can be tricky enough to communicate the software requirements and other specifics of your project without you and them also learning and implementing processes to respect domestic and foreign regulations. If you'd like more information, feel free to set up a call.SC
-
Where to incorporate a new software as a service busines?
I'll keep try to keep this answer brief, but there are several factors and nuances that can be discussed in more depth. Where you decide to incorporate partly depends on what your future goals are with your company. Companies that plan to seek venture capital or go public typically choose Delaware as the state of incorporation, and usually choose a C-Corp. Delaware has a very well developed body of law surrounding corporate governance and that provides comfort and more certainty to future VC investors. If you're not planning to seek VC money any time soon, an LLC is a smart decision because of the tax benefits it can provide to you as the owner. It sounds like you want to grow your company on your own without outside financing. If that's the case, I would recommend forming your LLC in California. Regarding California vs. Delaware, one benefit to forming your LLC in California is that you can avoid paying a registered agent fee which can cost anywhere from $100-200 a year. If you plan to seek venture capital down the road, you can reincorporate in Delaware.JI
the startups.com platform
Copyright © 2025 Startups.com. All rights reserved.