Loading...
Answers
MenuIn revenue based licensing deal, how can I make sure we are not being take advantage of when clients can't disclose information about their clients?
Hi,
We are a start-up company that licenses software and gets a percentage of net sales. To make sure we get the percentage of the sales, we ask for a copy of the contracts. However, one client told us that the licensing fees of their clients is confidential, so we have to trust them. What can be done in these cases? In revenue based deals, how can I make sure I got the right revenue and we are not taken advantage of?
Answers
The question that pops up for me from your question is, "Why would you trust someone who isn't behaving like a partner?"
How common is this situation, where a licensee declines to share buyer contract info with you? I'm guessing very infrequent from your description of "one" licensee behaving this way. If that is so, and the far more common situation is a licensee agreeing to share the end user contract data with you to have fully accurate revenue data, then I would simply screen out those potential licensees who won't cooperate and not work with them.
If, however, your marketplace sees the resistance to sharing data as being more commonplace, I would review the structure of how your software is being delivered. The software licensing program could capture this revenue data so you wouldn't have to worry about trusting licensees. An example of a third party licensing program I've seen (to which I am not in any way affiliated) is https://www.licensecloud.com/
As another option, you could also dispense entirely with the idea of following licensees around and making sure they're telling you the truth about revenue. Restructure your billing system so you charge a profitable flat fee per end user, and leave it up to your licensees to sell the services for whatever they are able. This keeps you out of the business of looking over your licensees' shoulders and in my opinion is healthier in many ways over the medium and long term.
Revenue models are tricky to calculate and many intelligent people will miss expensive cost factors on the road to developing a price that truly makes them money.
I help businesses who have any kind of problem on the path of competently delivering a product or service to their customer. If you'd like to discuss this further, reply here and send me a message because I don't always check previous threads.
Thanks,
Jason
Hi ,as a corporate lawyer I have dealt many times with licensing agreement and there are two things that are typically a part of these kind of agreements: A. the first one is auditing rights - that allows you to check the other side's books at all time including by a professional auditor (and if there are big discrepancies between what was reported and the actual sales they need to pay not only the difference, but also interest, a penalty and the fee of the auditor). B. you sign a mutual NDA that the auditor is obligated by it as well. They can quietly reveal their fee as you are obligated to keep it confidential or at least someone on your behalf can review it.
The question is, if you are getting a percentage - won't you know there fees anyway? What is their alternative? If you want, you can make an estimation and charge them a fixed licence fee.
My guess is that you don't want this to fall through so you need to find a creative solution.
Good luck
There is usually a reporting mechanism that includes non-identifiable information. Besides, If they are a reseller of your products then you have a right to know who the end user licensor is for contract and legal purposes. I would make this a requirement in order to work with you.
Plus you should have a good non-circumvention type clause with some sort of liquidated damages to ensure there are adequate remedies if you find out that this is happening.
Let me know if you would like to review some more options,
Thanks,
Madhu
Related Questions
-
How do I become a licensee of the NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL, NCAA/US Colleges, NASCAR?
A 0.31 second Google search located this: http://i.cdn.turner.com/nascar/.element/pdf/2.0/sect/kyn/NASCAR_Prospective_Licensing_Application.pdfSN
-
How can I sell a product with someone else's IP?
If the person doesn't have a patent, trademark, or copyright on the thing you want to copy, then you can copy as much as you want. Current IP law in the USA is "first to file" (see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_to_file_and_first_to_invent) If the person has any of those things, and you want to copy them legally then you have to ask them for a licence. If the person has any of those things, but doesn't have the money to sue you for infringement, then you might be able to copy it with legal repercussion. That wouldn't be very cool though.LV
-
How do I license out a product?
So this is a great question and requires a relatively complex answer. And this is NOT legal advice. The first answer is that No, in most cases do not patent the invention yet. Often a provisional patent will do just fine, much cheaper and faster to market. Most inventor patents out of the gate are a waste of time/money. Additionally, one license negotiation piece is that if you have the Prov Patent Application, (PPA) then you can have the licensee pay for the cost of YOUR patent. I recently interviewed licensing expert Stephen Key, NYT Bestselling author of One Simple Idea about this topic. You can listen if you'd like for free here: http://baconwrappedbusiness.com/stephen-key/ Hope this is helpfulBC
-
Should I be worried that a potential client wants us to guarantee that we will cover the litigation costs if they are sued for using our software?
I am a patent attorney generally on the patent owner's side. Signing such a clause should make you nervous. You don't want to be responsible for the major company's infringement. The major company is likely getting more benefit out of using your software than your company is making by selling licenses. The previous gentleman's answer is incorrect. Anyone can be sued for patent infringement if they make, sell, or *use* the claimed invention. It depends on the claims in the asserted patent. Based on experience, it's much more likely that the larger entity would be sued for infringement. A patent infringement case could cost anywhere between $350k-$5M+ USD. http://www.cnet.com/news/how-much-is-that-patent-lawsuit-going-to-cost-you/ In order to properly answer your question, I would need to know why you feel it's "very unlikely" that someone would sue the major company for using your software. If the major company won't back down on this provision, the best thing you can do is determine if you need IP (defense) insurance. If a patent attorney determines that it is necessary, raise the price of your license and get IP insurance.AP
-
What range of percentage of net sales is reasonably to ask for.
This is always a question of who wants whom more. I've seen deals where the percentage was in single digits. The thing is, I've seen both deals where a LICENSEE ended up with a single digit percentage and deals where a LICENSOR ended up with a single digit percentage. It all comes down to your ability to convince the other side that you are bringing in so much to the table that the other side should get a smaller piece of the pie. Essentially, this depends on these factors: - whether you are well-known in the industry; - whether the other side is well-known in the industry; - the level of uniqueness of your product (if you've developed another minor variation of a product that already exists on the market, chances are the distributor will want a larger piece of the pie); - your level of desperation (it's one thing when you partner up with someone else who will commercialize your product simply because you can make more money by investing your time building new stuff; it's another thing when you have no realistic way to commercialize the product yourself, and if you don't find someone who can do it for you quickly, you'll starve...) MOST IMPORTANTLY, no matter what number you agree to, make sure you read the contract extremely carefully. Contracts can create rights and contracts can destroy rights. Contracts are more powerful than any rights vested in you by IP laws. So, the bottom line is: - Know EXACTLY what you are trying to get out of your contract; - Get your contract reviewed by an experienced lawyer, but make sure you tell the lawyer what it is you're trying to get out of the contract. Lawyers are not going to create "the right deal" for you. We're not going to tell you whether you should be getting 9% or 90% of the revenue. We're going to make sure that you understand whether the contract you are about to sign reflects what you think the terms of the contract are. You're welcome to schedule a call if you would like to discuss this in more detail. Cheers, AndreiAM
the startups.com platform
Copyright © 2025 Startups.com. All rights reserved.