Loading...
Answers
MenuWhat do you understand by the term "deal crafting"?
This question has no further details.
Answers
Nothing. Business transactions should be spoken about in the plainest possible way. People using terms like this come across as lacking credibility (at least to me).
Besides, a deal is never crafted, it is always negotiated.
Crafting evokes a singular emphasis whereas a deal always involves two parties.
I would avoid using this term and avoid anyone who describes themselves as having this ability
Back in 2001, Havard had a Deal Crafing Toolkit what was used in some classes but I have never seen it beyond that reference. Even there the ultimate goal was to demonstrate the tension between creating and claiming value in negotiation.
"Deal Crafting" seems to imply that a particular deal can be manipulated in some way which is not what you want to happen in today's transparent environment. Not sure how the term is being used in your world but many could consider it a very negative phrase. My advice is to be very careful in using this term.
"Deal Crafting" accurately describes what I did for years as a business broker. Most business owners are expert at delivering their product or service, but most know very little about the purchase or sale of a business. This leaves two inexperienced and somewhat ignorant parties trying to fumble around and make a deal.
As a professional broker, I would add value by first assessing a realistic selling scenario for the business and then setting realistic expectations in the seller's mind. Once a buyer was found, I would work to educate the buyer on the process of buying a business and show them examples of how deals can be structured. By communicating with both parties and understanding their goals in the negotiation, I often made suggestions which lead to an ultimate successful deal.
I would imagine that this scenario can play out in many areas of business where you have infrequent transactions or inexperienced participants. For example, specialized purchasing consultants exist to help companies acquire machines and equipment that they may not regularly purchase.
Could you not say that a designer or decorator is helping to 'craft' the chef's new restaurant? There certainly are people out there who specialize in coaching or shepherding a negotiation. To the point of the earlier respondents, I ran into a large number of charlatans and con artists who claimed to be able to do what I did but could not.
I would recommend that you ask for references from both sides of past deals and follow them up if you ever go looking for this type of expertise.
Hope this helps.
Related Questions
-
How do you structure compensation for 2 advisors that want to be very actively involved / invested into our business that has sale potential soon?
One of the start-ups I'm involved with does a lot of work alongside entrepreneurs building companies towards an eventual exit or sale... Here's a couple of recommendations, aside from the usual "research what typical sales people in your industry get paid" advice: 1. Incentivize unexpected business. In other words, don't pay them too much to solicit or close business that would have been easy for you to get or would have fallen in your lap anyways. Consider having two pay tiers, one slightly lower tier for business you probably could have attained with any salesperson's help and one that contains the dream deals that you'd need a star salesperson to get. Pay them to go after your white whales (Moby Dick reference for anyone who is wondering). This may result in greater overall marketshare than if you just hired a couple salespeople, who will naturally go after the low hanging fruit first. 2. Create a CONTRIBUTION FORMULA for the eventual buyout. If you're looking for a good long-term kicker, give them a piece of the company, based on how much they actually contribute to the bottom line over the period from when they're hired to when the company sells (or they leave). In other words, you may say something like you'll give them up to 5% of the sales price of the company, depending on how much of the revenue they generate. If they generate 50% of the revenue, you'd give them 50% of 5% (or 2.5%) when the company eventually sells. 3. Ask them what would motivate them the most. Duh. How do we not ask our salespeople this more? If there's an answer that excites them more than what we're offering, why wouldn't we consider it, right? We want them as motivated as possible. Of course, before you say "yes" to anything they propose, run it by your mentors, the folks on Clarity.fm and your legal and accounting team. I'm happy to have a more in-depth conversation on the psychology of motivation and pay (I'll put on my psychology hat) or preparing a company to be sold for the best price possible (my MergerMatch.com hat). Reach out to me through Clarity.fm if I can help. Best of luck! Ken Clark Coach, consultant and therapist to entrepreneursKC
-
Should I charge a fixed fee or per lead for Engagement Marketing Services?
Charging per lead shows that you are setting your pricing based on the value you bring to clients, and that you are willing to put a personal stake in getting them results.LS
-
As an international deal broker, what is the standard commission rate?
Hi This highly depends on the industry and the country the parties are from. Each country and each industry has different rates. Finder's fee ranges from 3% - 10%. Real estate agent's fees range from 0.5% - 2.5% Commodities deal broker fees can range anywhere from 2% - 20% - it all depends on the deal and the value that you're bringing to both sides. The higher the value, the higher your fee may be. Either way, I suggest you sign both sides on a 'finders fee' or "broker" agreement I can help you draft one of these if you need. I've successfully helped over 300 entrepreneurs and would be happy to help you. After scheduling a call, please send me some background information so that I can prepare in advance - thus giving you maximum value for your money. Take a look at the great reviews I’ve received: https://clarity.fm/assafben-david Good luckAB
-
When going through an acquisition as a minority shareholder in a complex transaction, should I hire an expert "agent" to negotiate on my behalf?
The complexity of your situation is similar to multiple acquisitions I have encountered on both sides of the table in private and public transactions. In most situations involving private equity, it is doubtful if the additional cost of a private agent would generate a material gain given your minority position. However, since your situation has the additional complexities of differentiation in EBITDA contribution and negotiation with family members, I would agree with your recommendation to use an external agent. If the cost is a concern, you may want to consider using an advisor/coach/consultant to work on a fixed fee basis instead. I took this approach in selling one of the private companies I ran and was able to complete the transaction at a much lower cost than using an investment banker or agent. I'm happy to share my experience and lessons learned if you would like to follow up with a discussion.WV
-
We're looking to hire a seasoned COO. What package would you pay? cash/ equity mix probably flexible (our run-rate is c$3.5m pa).
Hi I have worked on executive compensation in multiple companies and I am presenting information based on my recent work in this area. COO salaries in the US will range from USD 105K to USD 268K depending upon experience, location & skills being hired. This will include base pay + 401(k) benefits + Performance incentive/bonus. If you are offering equity then thats an excellent negotiation tool. You would have to first decide what compensation positioning you want to take or have already taken wrt your existing talent at developer level. This can determine a pay range - then look at your budget & discuss with your recruitment partner if you can identify talent at that cost. Keep a range say from 75% to 90% of the compensation ratio as your target cost for a role like COO. Take a look at tools like Robert Half - rht.com. I am happy to help you with the details in case you want to do a more detailed analysis/study.AV
the startups.com platform
Copyright © 2025 Startups.com. All rights reserved.