Loading...
Answers
MenuCan you build a used car valuation product from Autotrader (or any other online classifieds) data?
Is the price in the listings statistically reliable? Is the data sufficient to build a model?
In my market, there is no car valuation product like KBB, so I'm wondering about building it from the car classifieds data.
Answers
Hmm .. Interesting that you say your sector isn't being addressed. Wonder why ... But if so, then that's an opportunity.
I've spent the past 4 years specializing in probably THE hardest market for making accurate appraisals: the domain name industry. For me as an engineer, that has meant crunching numbers. So I'm intimately familiar with the issues involved in making inferences about value from partial list-price and sale-price data.
In fact, I spend much of each day compiling raw data and building database-driven tools to organize and analyze it.
So I don't know the auto industry at all, but I know a thing or 2 about figuring out the value of assets in obscure areas.
Certainly a model can be constructed for extrapolating value from list prices. It only remains to be determined how wide the margin of error would be and what kind of latent bias might exist.
If you'd like my help, just ask.
Yes, I can help you build a used car valuation product using data from sources like Autotrader, Kelley Blue Book (KBB), Cars.com, CarGurus, etc.
Here’s how we can approach it:
⸻
Goal:
Create a web-based or API-based product that provides estimated value for used cars based on real-time market data.
⸻
Core Features:
1. User Input:
• Make, model, year
• Mileage
• Trim, condition
• Zip code or location
2. Data Collection (Scraping/API):
• Scrape real-time listings from Autotrader or other sites (unless APIs are available)
• Clean and aggregate data
3. Valuation Engine:
• Use regression or machine learning models to estimate value
• Optionally compare to official sources (KBB, NADA, Edmunds)
4. Interface:
• Simple web UI (Bubble, Webflow, or code-based)
• Or an API for integration into other tools
5. Optional Enhancements:
• Price trends over time
• Sellability score
• Alerts for deals on similar cars
⸻
Tech Stack (Options):
• Frontend/UI: Bubble, React, Next.js
• Backend/API: Python (FastAPI), Node.js
• Scraping: BeautifulSoup, Selenium, Playwright (or Scrapy)
• ML/Valuation: Scikit-learn or OpenAI fine-tuned model
• Database: PostgreSQL, Firebase, or MongoDB
⸻
Important Notes:
• Legal/Compliance: Web scraping from sites like Autotrader can violate terms of service. It’s better to use official APIs if available (e.g., KBB API, Carfax API).
• Rate Limits: If scraping, you’ll need rotating proxies and anti-bot strategies.
⸻
Would you like to:
1. Build a quick MVP using scraping?
2. Use legitimate API access (if you have or want to apply for it)?
3. Build just the valuation engine and UI without scraping?
Let me know your preferred direction and budget/tech preference, and I’ll map out a full plan or even build you a starter prototype.
Related Questions
-
When creating a marketplace, does it make more sense to focus on stimulating demand first or supply?
Focus on the more difficult side of the marketplace. For instance, if you think it'll be easier to get suppliers, then focus first on getting buyers - always be working on your toughest problem (aka your biggest risk). You'll find some great blogging on Marketplace and Platform topics here http://platformed.info (read the ebook too!)CM
-
What support software do most marketplace startups use? Is it custom, or a SaaS product like Zendesk, Desk.com or Uservoice
Your support software should cater to your needs, depending on how your business operates. Fiver uses Vanilla forum and Zendesk. Thumbtack uses Zendesk. Not sure about AirBNB, their help center seems to be custom. Depending on how well funded your are, I would recommend starting with a free plan with one of the help desk SaaS products, or even using open source ticketing platform. Then, as your needs grow and you need integration with your marketplace, there's no reason you can't scale and migrate.VN
-
Holding funds in a 2-sided marketplace?
Check out https://www.balancedpayments.com/ They are made for marketplaces. Airbnb CEO among others invested in them and they have some of the best pricing/payout fees. Also some good info on http://www.collaborativeconsumption.com/2013/10/08/online-marketplaces-are-hard/ One of Balanced Payments co-founders is writing this blog series on marketplaces.MA
-
Broad niche or Targeted niche which way to go?
I always suggest going "uncomfortably narrow" initially so that you can really dial in the user experience and build liquidity first. Going broad will be tougher as there's too much noise to signal. Also, it's best to fake the supply side initially of you can to improve the buyers side first, then figure out supply & quality afterwards if customers are buying and you've proven out a demand strategy that will work.DM
-
What is the best pricing (business model) to apply to a marketplace?
I like to separate your question into 2 sub-questions: #1 How do we determine which side to charge? #2 How much is the right amount to charge? On #1, my answer is that you can charge the side(s) for whom you add the most value. In your examples, Uber really solves a big problem for drivers, it's that they sit idle for a good part of the day, so are willing to pay a lot for new leads. (their alternative is no work) Consumers are charged more for the convenience of a private car but they are probably not so much willing to pay more for a taxi, even if they can hail one from their phones. For AirBnB, it's a mix, it's a way for landlords to monetize idle capacity which they are willing to pay for, but it's also a way for a renter to pay less than they would normally pay for a hotel. On #2 (how much), I like to triangulate a number of factors: - What's the maximum amount I can charge one side, while still being a good deal for them. - How much do I need to charge so that I can become profitable? (the economics are quite different if you charge 3% vs. 12%) - What are comparable services charging for substitutes/competitive offerings? I will just add that there is no formulaic way to determine pricing strategies (curated vs. open), and it's a lot more about what's the comparable and what the value delivered is. That's how I approached the question while deciding the business model at ProBueno.com (my startup)MR
the startups.com platform
Copyright © 2025 Startups.com. All rights reserved.